Apricate.dev

What happens if the Cloud Controller Manager fails in a cloud-hosted Kubernetes cluster?

Written by

Bohdan

in

If the Cloud Controller Manager (CCM) fails in a cloud-hosted Kubernetes cluster, it can disrupt the integration between Kubernetes and the underlying cloud provider. While the cluster’s core functionality may still operate, several cloud-specific features and resources could be impacted. Here’s what happens and how to mitigate the effects:

Potential Impacts of a CCM Failure

1. Node Lifecycle Management

  • Problem: The CCM’s Node Controller won’t update node statuses.
  • Impact:
    • If a cloud auto-scaler removes a node, Kubernetes may not recognize the change, leaving orphaned node objects in the cluster.
    • Workloads might not be rescheduled to other healthy nodes.

2. Load Balancer Provisioning

  • Problem: The Service Controller cannot create, update, or delete cloud Load Balancers for Services of type LoadBalancer.
  • Impact:
    • New Services of type LoadBalancer will fail to provision external IPs.
    • Existing Load Balancers may become outdated if Service configurations are modified.

3. Persistent Volume Management

  • Problem: The Volume Controller cannot provision or manage cloud storage volumes.
  • Impact:
    • PersistentVolumeClaims (PVCs) relying on dynamic provisioning will not be fulfilled.
    • Volumes may not be properly attached, detached, or resized.

4. Route Management

  • Problem: The Route Controller won’t update network routes.
  • Impact:
    • Inter-node Pod communication in cloud networks requiring custom routes may fail, potentially leading to network disruptions for multi-node workloads.

5. Cluster Resource Drift

  • Problem: The CCM fails to reconcile cloud resources with Kubernetes objects.
  • Impact:
    • Cloud resources may become stale or inconsistent with Kubernetes configurations, leading to operational inefficiencies.

Behavior of Other Control Plane Components

  • The API Server, Scheduler, and Controller Manager remain operational because they do not depend directly on the CCM for their core functionality.
  • Workloads running on existing nodes continue to operate as long as they do not require cloud resource changes (e.g., volume reattachments or new Load Balancers).

Troubleshooting a CCM Failure

  1. Inspect CCM Logs:
    • Use the following command to review logs for errors or failures:
      • kubectl logs -n kube-system <cloud-controller-manager-pod>
  2. Check Cloud Provider APIs:
    • Verify that the cloud provider’s APIs are operational and accessible.
    • Look for rate limits, authentication issues, or API outages.
  3. Validate CCM Configuration:
    • Check the CCM configuration files (e.g., credentials, endpoint URLs) for errors.
    • Ensure cloud credentials are valid and have sufficient permissions.
  4. Monitor Kubernetes Events:
    • Inspect events related to Services, PersistentVolumes, or Nodes for clues:
      • kubectl get events --all-namespaces
  5. Restart the CCM Pod:
    • If the CCM is running as a pod, restarting it might resolve transient issues:
      • kubectl delete pod -n kube-system <cloud-controller-manager-pod>

Mitigating the Risks of a CCM Failure

  1. High Availability Setup
    • Deploy multiple replicas of the CCM with leader election enabled to ensure failover.
  2. Cloud API Rate Limits
    • Use rate limiting or API quotas to prevent exceeding the cloud provider’s limits.
  3. Monitoring and Alerts
    • Set up monitoring (e.g., Prometheus, Grafana) to track CCM health and performance.
    • Configure alerts for failed resource provisioning or degraded CCM performance.
  4. Static Provisioning (Temporary Fix)
    • For PersistentVolumes: Manually provision cloud storage and link it to a PersistentVolume object in Kubernetes.
    • For Load Balancers: Manually create cloud Load Balancers and update Service configurations with external IPs.
  5. Backups and Fallback Plans
    • Maintain backups of critical cluster configurations (e.g., manifests, etcd snapshots) for quick recovery.

Cluster Recovery Plan

  1. Restore CCM Operations:
    • Fix configuration or cloud connectivity issues to bring the CCM back online.
  2. Reconcile Resources:
    • Manually reconcile any discrepancies in cloud resources (e.g., reattach volumes or update Load Balancers).
  3. Audit Cluster State:
    • After recovery, audit cluster objects (Services, PersistentVolumes, Nodes) to ensure they align with cloud resources.

Summary

While a CCM failure doesn’t bring down the entire Kubernetes cluster, it disrupts critical cloud-specific functionalities like Load Balancer management, volume provisioning, and route updates. Monitoring, high availability, and prompt troubleshooting are essential to minimize the impact of such failures.

More posts